Jolie Hoang-Rappaport as Zoe:Erin's daughter who later becomes a protector of the cookbook. Zoe also appears in Just Add Magic.

Tyler Sanders as Leo: New protector of the cookbook. Leo is Nick's son and Zoe's step-brother. Leo is very interested in superhero and art.

Jenna Qureshi as Ish/Ishita: New protector of the cookbook. She is Zoe and Leo's neighbor.

Matt Dellapina as Nick Sellitti: Erin's new husband who owns his own restaurant

Tess Paras as Erin Chua: Springtown Coffee manager who takes over Mama P's Cafe for a time and later moves to Silver City to marry Nick.

James Urbaniak as Pierce Hamilton: The villain of the story who is desperate to beat Zoe, Leo, and Ish in solving the mystery

Casey Simpson as Cody Hamilton: Pierce's son who likes spending time with his family solving the mystery.

Sydney Taylor as Lexi Hamilton: Pierce's daughter who is good friends with Ish.

Shane Harper as Ian Maddox: Past protector revealed to be Zoe's father. Erin's late Husband and the father of her daughter.